How to Win the Credit Card Game
Credit cards shouldn't be confusing. Instead of a random list of offers, pick the single strategy that matches your current goal.
Key Takeaways
- Never pay interest. Rewards are worthless if you carry a balance
- Chase 5/24 Rule: Always prioritize Chase cards first
- Pick a strategy: Cash Back (Simple) or Travel Points (Max Value)
- The Chase Sapphire Preferred is the best starter travel card
- Treat credit cards like debit cards—only spend what you have
The Builder
"I have no credit or bad credit. I need to get approved and build my score."
The Saver
"I want simple cash back. No annual fees, no tracking points, no stress."
The Explorer
"I want to travel for free. Give me the highest value rewards possible."
The Optimizer
"I want VIP perks—lounge access, upgrades, and elite status."
| Persona | Best For | Key Feature | Recommended Card |
|---|---|---|---|
| 🌱 The Builder | Building/Fixing Credit | No credit score required | Discover it® Secured |
| 🐷 The Saver | Simplicity & Cash Back | Flat rate on everything | Citi Double Cash® |
| ✈️ The Explorer | Free Travel | Transferable points | Chase Sapphire Preferred |
| 💎 The Optimizer | Luxury & Status | Lounge access & credits | Chase Sapphire Reserve® |
The Builder
Goal: Establish a credit history and reach a 700+ score.
The Problem: You can't get a good card without credit, but you can't get credit without a card.
Your Move: Discover it® Secured
This is the only secured card that matters. You put down a deposit (usually $200), which becomes your credit limit. Unlike other secured cards, it earns rewards and has a clear path to "graduation."
- ✅ No Credit Score Needed: Designed specifically for beginners with zero history.
- ✅ Earns Rewards: 2% cash back at gas stations and restaurants.
- ✅ Automatic Review: After 7 months, Discover automatically reviews your account to upgrade you.
🚪 Exit Strategy: When to Graduate
This card is a temporary tool. After 7 months of on-time payments, Discover will graduate you to an unsecured card and refund your deposit. No need to cancel and lose your history.
The Builder's Playbook
The Saver
Goal: Maximize cash in your pocket with zero effort.
The Strategy: Ignore "points." Ignore "categories." Just get a flat-rate card that pays you for breathing.
Your Move: Citi Double Cash®
The king of simplicity. You earn 2% on literally everything. No caps, no categories, no annual fee.
- ✅ 2% Everywhere: 1% when you buy, 1% when you pay.
- ✅ $0 Annual Fee: It costs nothing to keep.
- ✅ Set and Forget: Use this for every single purchase.
🚪 Exit Strategy: Life-Long Keeper
Since this card has $0 annual fee, keep it open forever to help your average age of accounts and credit score.
High-Asset Alternative: Premium Rewards®
If you have over $100k in assets with Merrill Edge/BofA, the "Platinum Honors" tier gives you a 75% bonus on all rewards.
- ✅ 2.62% Catch-All: Earn 2.62% cash back on everything (vs. 2% normally).
- ✅ 3.5% Dining & Travel: Uncapped rewards on these categories.
- ✅ $100 Travel Credit: Covers the $95 annual fee completely, making the card effectively free.
The Explorer
Goal: Free flights and hotel stays.
The Strategy: Earn "transferable points" (Chase Ultimate Rewards) that are worth more than cash.
Your Move: Chase Sapphire Preferred®
The undisputed best starter card for travel. The sign-up bonus alone is often worth $750-$1,000 in travel.
- ✅ Huge Bonus: Usually 60,000+ points after minimum spend.
- ✅ Transfer Partners: Move points 1:1 to United, Southwest, and Hyatt.
- ✅ Travel Protection: Includes primary rental car insurance.
🚪 Exit Strategy: When to Downgrade
If you decide after Year 1 that you don't want it, call Chase and "Product Change" to a Freedom card ($0 fee). This preserves your points and credit history.
Premium Alternative: Chase Sapphire Reserve®
If you travel frequently (5+ trips/year), the $550 annual fee is deceptive. The math often works out better than the Preferred.
- ✅ $300 Travel Credit: Automatically erased from your bill, making the effective fee $250.
- ✅ Airport Lounges: Full Priority Pass Select membership (with restaurant access).
- ✅ 50% Point Bonus: Points are worth 1.5¢ each on the portal (vs 1.25¢ on Preferred).
The Optimizer
Goal: Luxury perks and maximum value extraction.
The Strategy: Choose your ecosystem. You can be on Team Amex or Team Chase. Both offer elite perks, but for different lifestyles.
Path A: Team Amex
The Card: The Platinum Card® from American Express ($895).
The ultimate lifestyle card. It's expensive, but if you travel, the credits can outweigh the fee.
Pro Tip: The "Amex Duo"
Pair the Platinum with the Amex Gold to earn 4x on Dining and Groceries.
Path B: Team Chase
The Card: Chase Sapphire Reserve® ($795).
A easier-to-justify premium card. The $300 travel credit applies automatically to any travel purchase.
Pro Tip: The "Chase Trifecta"
Pair the Reserve with the Freedom Flex and Unlimited ($0 annual fee).
Path C: The Delta Loyalist
The Card: Delta SkyMiles® Platinum American Express Card ($350).
The fastest way to earn Delta Medallion® Status. This card is a must-have for anyone who flies Delta regularly and wants a shortcut to elite perks.
The Status Shortcut
Earn $2,500 MQDs (Medallion Qualification Dollars) each year just for holding the card—putting you halfway to Silver Medallion Status automatically.
- ✅ MQD Headstart: Start each year with 2,500 MQDs.
- ✅ Annual Companion Certificate: Domestic Main Cabin round-trip every year upon renewal.
- ✅ First Checked Bag Free: Saves up to $140 per roundtrip for a family of four.
Why I Stopped Using...
American Express® Gold Card
🏆 The Former Champion
Excellent earner for dining and groceries (4x points). A staple of the Amex ecosystem for years.
🛑 The Dealbreaker
The annual fee became difficult to justify. Managing monthly credits (Uber Cash, dining credits) to extract value felt like a chore.
🚪 My Move
Cancelled. Simplified setup with cards that don't require monthly maintenance to justify their cost.
Alaska Airlines Visa Signature® (BofA)
🏆 The Former Champion
Great for Alaska loyalists, especially the annual companion fare (buy one ticket, get one for ~$100).
🛑 The Dealbreaker
My travel patterns shifted. While the companion pass is valuable, I wasn't flying routes that made it worthwhile.
🚪 My Move
I switched to the Bank of America® Premium Rewards® card. With Platinum Honors status, it earns 2.62% cash back on everything, beating the Alaska miles for my usage.
US Bank Altitude® Reserve
🏆 The Former Champion
It earned 4.5% cash back on all Apple Pay purchases. It was my favorite "catch-all" card for years.
🛑 The Dealbreaker
US Bank removed the mobile wallet bonus category in Dec 2025, making the fee impossible to justify.
🚪 My Move
I downgraded it to the no-fee Altitude® Connect card after capturing the final credits.
My Actual Wallet Setup (2026)
I prioritize simplicity and value. I use a two-card setup that covers 95% of my spending.
The "Platinum Honors" Combo
- ✈️ Chase Sapphire Reserve®: My travel card. I use it for the travel insurance, lounge access, and "Points Boost" redemptions.
- 📈 Bank of America® Premium Rewards®: My dining and "everything else" card. With Platinum Honors, this earns 3.5% back on dining and 2.62% on everything else.
🛑 The 2 Golden Rules
1. Never Pay Interest
If you carry a balance, you lose. The interest rates on rewards cards are predatory (25%+). Always use Autopay for the full statement balance.
2. Respect 5/24
Chase will auto-deny you if you've opened 5+ cards in 24 months. Prioritize Chase cards first before moving to other banks. Read the 5/24 Guide.
Ready to start?
If you're unsure, the Chase Sapphire Preferred® is the most versatile starting point for 90% of people.
ⓘ Links on this page may earn us a commission at no cost to you. We only recommend products we actually use and love. Learn more
📚 Citing This Guide
When referencing this content, please cite: "How to Win the Credit Card Game" by jason.guide
